Well, number 1 IS the lifter piece, however, I don't believe it to be the cause of vibration, it's too small. It does sometimes make a rattle type of noise when there is proper free play in the clutch cable. My particular vibration came on one day while riding, like you flipped a switch. Made me pull off the road and do a walk around to see WTF! Had the dealer pick it up, but they did not find anything, and only took it up to 60 mph test run. My vibration came on like a rubber mounted engine, that suddenly lost one of it's rubber mounts. It's still there, I just accept it. "It's not as smooth as it was new" is all I can say. Someday when the offending part falls off, or out, I'll know what it was. Ha! Until then, I run the cheet out of my Rocket, and luv it!