I don't doubt your "theory" on the loss of HP Art.
Well, not much anyway.
Considering the car tire is bigger with more surface to have to spin
compared to the smaller footprint of the metz.
That makes sense.
I would like to see the HP numbers though.
As far as riding in the rain,
it's inevitable for me, I ride, I don't pull over.
I live on a dirt/gravel road with a hill at the end before I can taste the blacktop,
so if I want to ride, I deal with the circumstances.
But thats just me.
I guess IF I only rode on ideal surfaces in track conditions with perfect weather,
maybe a metz would be ok,
but for me,
in my riding conditions,
I'll take the car tire.