My dealer said to run 89 in it, yet the owners manual says 87. So which is correct? Am I wasting money on the 89 since the engine has such a relatively low compression?
In the US, the number on the pump is the AKI (anti knock index). Its equal to the average of the MON (motor octane number) and the RON (research octane number). How a fuel actually performs is dependent on the AKI and the Sensitivity (the difference between the MON and the RON). And then there is the calorific value, and the propensity to combust (combustion efficiency).
I've had two different R3Ts. I live in a hilly area, and I used to weigh 340 pounds.
What I noticed is that, under heavy load (340 pound me going up a steep hill at 50 mph), there is a tendency for my Rockets to knock. A downshift can take care of it with nearly any fuel. It is less of an issue with real 93 octane gasoline.
Under lighter loads (224 pound me on a level road) my Rockets don't care what the octane level is, but I still prefer real 93 octane gasoline.
Right now, there is a lot of research being conducted that shows that higher octane fuels have the potential to be more efficient under modern engine control and sensing. As the US moves towards the 2025 CAFE target of 54.5 mpg, higher octane fuels are expected to play a role.
As for the gasohol (typically E10 nowadays in the US), the difference in mpg that most people will see is on the order of a few percent. The calorific value of the fuel on a gravimetric basis is very close to normal gasoline (E0). The actual weight per gallon for the E10 is slightly higher than the E0. So it turns out that the real differences are small, and most likely attributable to driving habits, and wishful perceptions.
I could get anywhere from 33 mpg to nearly 40 mpg out of my R3Ts. The biggest factor seems to be city vs. highway, and the right wrist.
So ... after all that BS, what do I do?
I buy the 93 octane premium gasoline that they sell near the lake for boaters. Its got the full complement of additives (anti foaming, detergent, etc), and its blended so that the AKI is at 93. The chances of having a fuel problem with this stuff is somewhere between 0 and epsilon.
If I'm on a trip, I nearly always end up with E10, and if its in one of the highway robbery states where gasoline is typically 30% more than in my home state, I'll buy the 87 regular grade.