Like others I've looked at and considered Indian too, allot of it to be/have something different. I really like the looks of the Indian Vintage but as you say, lots of coin for what you get. Another draw back to Indian, besides lack of Rocket type performance, is the bikes are now Polaris brand, the same company that discontinued Victory. Victory is no longer manufactured which means OEM parts supplies will dry up. Same thing could certainly happen to the Indian line, depending on sales, and it's darn rare to see an Indian on the road, at least around where I Live. On the other hand, there are allot of Vics on the road and Vic got dumped anyways. I'm think'n Polaris could dump Indian at any time.